Harold Halibut: All Water Brother IV and Family Ties Guide
Learn how to find all four All Water brothers, including the mysterious fourth brother Warren, to unlock the Family Ties (And Uniforms) trophy in Harold Halibut.
In the world of Harold Halibut, the All Water Corporation maintains its presence throughout the Fedora ship via a set of identical brothers serving as Secretaries. While players frequently interact with Secretaries 8, 17, and 24, there is a fourth brother, often referred to as Brother IV or "Wayward Warren," who has abandoned corporate life. Finding and interacting with all four siblings across multiple chapters is essential for completing the Family Ties (And Uniforms) trophy.
The All Water Secretaries
The majority of the brothers are loyal employees of the All Water Corporation, distinguished by their numerical designations. Despite their identical appearance, they hold different stations and views on their family dynamic.
- Secretary #8: Located at Central Station, typically positioned between the tube leading to All Water/Utility and the tubes for other districts. He considers himself the "natural leader" and "shining example" of the quadruplets, though he admits the family suffered a "schism" due to the actions of the fourth brother.
- Secretary #17: Stationed at the entrance to the Agora Arcade. He manages the monthly All Water Raffle Bonanza. He is noted by his brothers for inheriting the "maths gene," though perhaps not the "humor gene."
- Secretary #24: Found at the All Water Office. He is often the most vocal about the "sorted affair" regarding their fourth sibling, describing his brother's departure as a choice of "gastronomic frivolity" over societal contribution.
The Fourth Brother: Warren
The fourth brother, Warren, is not a member of the All Water Corporation. According to dialogue with Secretary #24, Warren attempted to join the company but failed the entrance exam. His brothers suspect his heart was never truly in corporate service.
Following his failure to join All Water, Warren embarked on a "culinary pilgrimage" across the station to find inspiration. He eventually opened a food stall called Water Weiners in the Agora Arcade. Unlike his brothers, who wear the standard All Water uniform, Warren is identified by his role as a hot dog vendor. His brothers remain somewhat "morose" about his departure, suggesting that while they were once a tight-knit family of quadruplets, Warren is now the "even one out."
Gameplay Video Reference
!(Harold Halibut Gameplay)(https://img.youtube.com/vi/YdkYoLsOgnY/hqdefault.jpg) Gameplay video reference: Harold searching for the Blue Rock and interacting with the All Water Secretaries.
Family Ties (And Uniforms) Trophy Walkthrough
To earn this trophy, Harold must engage in specific conversations with the brothers throughout the game's narrative. Community guides indicate that these steps are highly missable if skipped during their respective chapters.
Chapter 1 (Sections 1.3 or 1.4)
- Talk to Secretary #17 at the Agora Arcade entrance. This interaction triggers an optional task to inquire about the fourth brother.
- Speak with Secretary #8 at Central Station regarding the fourth brother.
- Talk to Secretary #24 at the All Water office.
- Return to Secretary #17 at the Arcade. Successfully completing these dialogues should grant the notebook entry "The Brothers of 3 brothers and a ?."
Chapter 2 (Section 2.1)
- Locate Warren at his "Water Weiners" stand in the Arcade Shop area (near the base of the stairs).
- Cycle through the brothers again: Speak to Secretary #17 (Arcade), Secretary #8 (Central Station), and Secretary #24 (All Water).
- Return to Warren at the Arcade. This updates the notebook entry "The Brothers" to feature all four siblings pictured together.
Chapter 4 (Section 4.4)
- Talk to Secretary #24 in the bathroom during the "Final Preparations" phase of the main story.
- Watch the A Capella Performance: Head to the stage at the Agora Arcade to watch the brothers perform together. This is part of the "A Capella Task."
- Note: This must be completed before attending Cyrus’s Green Thumb Class, or the opportunity will be missed. The trophy typically unlocks upon viewing this performance.
Sibling Lore and Dynamics
The relationship between the brothers is defined by a mix of professional pride and personal resentment. Secretary #8 mentions that because Warren is technically the youngest by a few minutes, he may have resented the others. The brothers often joke about their "quadruplet" status and the "taxing" nature of their simultaneous birth.
While the Secretaries are focused on "approachable and accountable" corporate service—managing the ship's day/night cycle, tube transportation, and energy budgets—Warren's pursuit of "gastronomic frivolity" serves as a rare example of a character breaking away from the All Water Corporation's pervasive influence on the Fedora.
FAQ
Where is the fourth brother in Harold Halibut? Warren, the fourth brother, is found in the Agora Arcade starting in Chapter 2. He sells hot dogs at a stall called Water Weiners.
How do I get the Family Ties trophy? You must speak to all three Secretaries (#8, #17, and #24) and Warren in Chapters 1 and 2, then witness their A Capella performance in Chapter 4.
Why did Warren leave All Water? Warren failed the corporate entrance exam. While his brothers claim he didn't study enough, they also believe his heart wasn't in it, leading him to pursue a career in food service instead.
Related Guides
Comprehensive Guide to Harold Halibut Characters
Meet the cast of Harold Halibut, including protagonist Harold, Professor Jeanne Mareaux, and the alien Weeoo in this handcrafted narrative adventure.
Harold Halibut Alien Ocean and Story World Guide
Explore the alien ocean setting of Harold Halibut, a handmade narrative game set on a city-sized spaceship with stop-motion clay aesthetics.
Harold Halibut Ending Explained
An analysis of Harold's final choice, the concept of 'happiness within uncertainty,' and the resolution of the Fedora 1's journey.
Harold Halibut Story Summary
A comprehensive summary of the narrative, characters, and setting of Harold Halibut, a handcrafted adventure set on a sunken spaceship city.